No products
-
-
-
Chef Hat - Chocolate Chipper
Other: Chocolate Chippers white hat. Has some dark marks on the front.
$8.00In Stock -
G3 Valentine's Tin
Valentine's Day Tin from 2006. Tin has been opened and has some minor paint wear in spots. Latch closes firmly and handle is in good condition. Measures approximately 4" x 4". Features Sweetberry, Sunny Daze, and Starswirl. There is a small dent.
$10.00In Stock -
Wave 3- Glow Twilight Sparkle (12)
This blind bag pony comes in an unopened package. This is the USA release with only English on the card, not the European one with multiple languages.
$20.00In Stock -
-
Wave 1- Flower Wishes (12)
This blind bag pony comes in an unopened package. This is the USA release with only English on the card, not the European one with multiple languages.
$5.00In Stock -
Wave 1- Lily Blossom (08)
This blind bag pony comes in an unopened package. This is the USA release with only English on the card, not the European one with multiple languages.
$5.00In Stock
-
Unicorn Sinner Sticker
Proudly proclaim your allegiance with the devil by displaying this holographic unicorn sticker! Measures 3" x 3" and is holographic. THIS IS A PRE-ORDER. Stickers will ship no later than 6/1/2026
$5.00In Stock -
Baby Bottle- Pink
This pink and white baby bottle was included with: Baby Firefly, Baby Cotton Candy, Baby Lickity Split, Baby Lofty, Bootsy/Tootsie. Baby Gusty is for size comparison only and is not included.
$1.00In Stock -
-
Baby Bottle- Yellow
This yellow and white baby bottle was included with: Baby Cotton Candy, Baby Gusty, Baby Shady, or Lullaby Nursery. Baby Gusty is for size comparison only and is not included.
$1.00In Stock -
Baby Bottle- White
This smaller version of the pony baby bottle came with the newborn twins. Baby Gusty is for size comparison only and is not included.
$4.00In Stock -
Diaper
Baby Pony Diapers came with numerous baby ponies, including the first set, beddy bye eyes, newborns, newborn twins, and the Lullaby Nursery.
$1.00In Stock -
Sweetie Belle
This version of Sweetie Belle was released in 2008 and came with the Sweet Sundae Amusement Park or Deliver Goodies.
$5.00In Stock -
-
-
-
We Ship Worldwide
Sorry, shipments cannot be made to Equestria, Narnia, Middle Earth, or Italy. Mars is a maybe.
-
Customer Service
Questions? We've got answers.
-
Secure Payment
All payments are processed through with Comodo SSL, ensuring even Tirek couldn't pry your information from the ether.
The New Gray Mare
This store is only a portion of the much larger New Gray Mare website. Don't be afraid to jump over to the other side of this marvelous site and explore:
Upcoming Events - 2022
March
- 20th Columbus Toy Show - https://www.ctspromotions.com/
- 26th Great Ohio Toy Show -https://www.facebook.com/ohiotoys/
April
- 8th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
- 9th Queen City Doll Show - https://www.facebook.com/Queen-City-Beautiful-Doll-Club-Show-Sale-110938920472088/
May
- 13th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
June
- 10th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
- 25-26th My Little Pony Fair - https://www.mylittleponycon.com/
July
- 15th-17th TrotCon - https://trotcon.net/
August
- 28th Columbus Toy Show - https://www.ctspromotions.com/