No products
-
Shoes- Yellow Bow
These yellow, bow shoes came with the Pony Wear sets Flashprance, Neon Lights, Get Into the Groove, and the Winter Pack.
$1.00In Stock -
Sweetie Belle- Rainbow Rocks
Pony is in excellent, near-new shape. She has been professionally cleaned and her hair conditioned and flat ironed.
$12.00Out of stock -
Paint and Marker Activity Book
Brand new and unused activity book including stickers!
$5.00In Stock -
Applejack
Hair: Soft, shiny, and uncut. Tail washer has been removed Eyes: Significant rub to display side eye.t Cutie Mark: Perfect Other: Minor pox along bottoms of feet
$15.00In Stock -
Wave 4- Electric Sky (9)
This blind bag pony comes in an unopened package. This is the USA release with only English on the card, not the European one with multiple languages.
$7.00In Stock -
Stack Toy Ring- White
This is the next to bottom ring for a stack toy. It goes to a number of baby ponies, some of which include Baby Glory, Baby Surprise, Baby Quackers, Baby Tic-Tac-Toe, Baby Dots'N'Hearts, Baby Splashes, Baby Starburst, Pockets/Hoppy, Fleecy/Wooly, and Paradise Estate.
$2.00In Stock -
Princess Cadance and Applejack
Hair: Cadance: Soft and uncut. Applejack: Soft and uncut; still in original plastic ties. Eyes: Perfect on both Cutie Mark: Perfect on both Other: These two are 100% complete and come with Princess Cadances crow, a bracelet, and two heart barrettes.
$10.00In Stock -
Flippity Flop
Hair: Soft and uncut Eyes: Perfect Cutie Mark: Perfect Other: Body is super clean and bright with no major flaws.
$10.00In Stock
-
Unicorn Sinner Sticker
Proudly proclaim your allegiance with the devil by displaying this holographic unicorn sticker! Measures 3" x 3" and is holographic.
$5.00In Stock -
-
-
Changeling Parasprite
This handmade parasprite comes in a 1 tall bottle. Fully hand sculpted and painted! It has iridescent wings and is suspended in the jar. Be sure not to open or you might have an infestation on your hands! Please note: Item is Made To Order and may take up to 1 week to complete before shipping.
$5.00In Stock -
Toothpaste- Green
Green toothpaste from First Tooth Ponies. It most likely came with Baby Tic Tac Toe.
$4.00In Stock -
Diaper
Baby Pony Diapers came with numerous baby ponies, including the first set, beddy bye eyes, newborns, newborn twins, and the Lullaby Nursery.
$1.00In Stock -
Sweetie Belle
This version of Sweetie Belle was released in 2008 and came with the Sweet Sundae Amusement Park or Deliver Goodies.
$5.00In Stock -
StarSong
StarSong was released with the Bumper Cars with Pinkie Pie and StarSong, Music with StarSong, Ponyville Adventure Game, and Family Dollar sets. She is in good shape with paint wear to her mane and tail, hoof heart, and wings.
$2.00In Stock -
-
-
TEMPORARILY: SHIPPING TO USA ONLY
We Ship Worldwide
Sorry, shipments cannot be made to Equestria, Narnia, or Middle Earth. Mars is a maybe.
-
Customer Service
Questions? We've got answers.
-
Secure Payment
All payments are processed through with Comodo SSL, ensuring even Tirek couldn't pry your information from the ether.
The New Gray Mare
This store is only a portion of the much larger New Gray Mare website. Don't be afraid to jump over to the other side of this marvelous site and explore:
Upcoming Events - 2022
March
- 20th Columbus Toy Show - https://www.ctspromotions.com/
- 26th Great Ohio Toy Show -https://www.facebook.com/ohiotoys/
April
- 8th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
- 9th Queen City Doll Show - https://www.facebook.com/Queen-City-Beautiful-Doll-Club-Show-Sale-110938920472088/
May
- 13th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
June
- 10th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
- 25-26th My Little Pony Fair - https://www.mylittleponycon.com/
July
- 15th-17th TrotCon - https://trotcon.net/
August
- 28th Columbus Toy Show - https://www.ctspromotions.com/